Island Cravings: These are my 5 Must-Eats on PEI I Drive Across the Island For

I live here. I eat here. I know this Island like the back of my hand—and let me tell you, I don’t take my meals lightly.

Prince Edward Island might be famous for beaches and Anne of Green Gables, but if you ask me, the real heart of this place? It’s in the food. Not just the seafood (though, yes, it’s next level), but the local gems, the comfort food, the spots that hit different after a beach day, or a long work week, or when you're craving something that just slaps.

These five places aren’t just “nice options” or “worth a try”—they’re my ride-or-dies. The places I dream about mid-winter. The ones I recommend before someone even finishes asking, “Where should I eat?”

Here are my 5 personal must-eats on PEI—coming from someone who lives here, loves food, and will always chase a great bite.

🥩 1. Sims Corner Steakhouse & Oyster Bar – Charlottetown

📍 Best For: Fine dining, surf & turf, and unforgettable Brussels sprouts

This downtown Charlottetown gem is upscale without the ego. The steaks are everything you want them to be—juicy, tender, and cooked to perfection. The lobster? Local and buttery. But let me tell you the real showstopper: the crispy, caramelized Brussels sprouts. Dream-worthy. Life-altering. Worth the parking hunt.

🍽 My go-to: Rare tenderloin topped with a fresh lobster tail, served with creamy garlic mashed potatoes and those crispy, caramelized Brussels sprouts I dream about. Perfectly paired with a bold red that brings it all together.

🦪 2. Sea Rocket Oyster House – Charlottetown

📍 Best For: Oysters, the vibrant decor, and pork belly perfection

If you love fresh oysters, Sea Rocket will have you hooked. The vibe is chill, the seafood is elite, and the scallop + pork belly dish will haunt your dreams (in the best way).

It’s the kind of place where the food tastes like PEI itself—fresh, honest, and unforgettable.

🍽 My go-to: Start with a dozen fresh-shucked oysters and a sharable charcuterie board, then dive into the pork belly and scallops—rich, tender, and unforgettable. All paired with a spicy Caesar that kicks things up just right.

🍔 3. Dingers Dive – Montague

📍 Best For: Fast food made from scratch, beach snacks, and road trip pit stops

This hidden gem in Montague (litterally hidden you might actual miss it) serves the best chicken burger I’ve had anywhere—full stop. And those skin-on fresh cut fries? They deserve their own fan club.

It’s a tiny, blink-and-you’ll-miss-it spot—pickup only, no dine-in—but don’t let the size fool you. Dingers serves up comfort food disguised as fast food. Everything’s homemade, full of flavor, and made with serious love.

🍽 My go-to: Classic chicken burger combo with fresh-cut fries—doused in malt vinegar and a sprinkle of salt—plus a cold can of Coke Zero to wash it all down. Simple. Perfect.

🧀 4. Slyamaker & Nichols – Charlottetown

📍 Best For: Charcuterie boards, date nights, and moody cocktails

A little moody, a little magical—Slyamaker & Nichols is where you go when you want to feel like you’ve entered a Netflix rom-com set in the Maritimes. Their charcuterie board is a masterclass in balance: salty, sweet, crunchy, rich. Every single item is sourced and plated with intention.

🍽 My go-to: Their signature charcuterie board loaded with local meats and cheeses, paired with a tiramisu espresso martini that tastes like dessert in a glass. Sophisticated, satisfying, and straight-up addictive.

🍟 5. Island Stone Pub – Kensington

📍 Best For: Burgers worth the drive, laid-back vibes, and hearty comfort food

Right in the Heart of Kensington, this spot was the old train station that is now my not-so-secret burger destination. It’s juicy. It’s messy in the right way. And it’s exactly what you want when you're on your way to—or from—the mainland.

It’s one of those no-fuss places where the food does the talking.

🍽 My go-to: The Classic Burger—stacked with American cheese, crisp lettuce, onion, tomato, pickle, and mayo—served with golden PEI fries and an ice-cold draft beer. Simple, nostalgic, and absolutely worth the drive.

🧭 Final Bite

Whether you’re a local Islander looking to shake up your weekend eats or a visitor building the ultimate PEI foodie itinerary, these are the places that deliver every time. These are the spots I send friends, family, and followers to. Because on PEI, eating well isn’t just a bonus—it’s part of the experience.

Tag me when you try them. I want to see what you order.

Sara

Nine02 Travel Hub

nine02.ca